Sunday, May 10, 2020

Post #6 of the Quarantine series - India's monetary indicators



 The central bank 🏦 is responsible for printing money 💵💴in the economy🇮🇳 which in turn flows into the entire economic system via different channels 🔂🔃🔄♻️and aids in various economic activities. The money with an individual👨🦰 can either be hoarded beneath one’s bed🛏️, spent for a purpose or can be deposited into one’s bank account. If the money is deposited, part of this money will in turn be lent to some other person🤓, who will deposit the money in his/her bank account. This process continues again and again which brings me to a popular idea in monetary economics called as 💡 “money multiplier”💡. This is just one of the many ratios and thus in Post 6️⃣ of the Quarantine series we will look at different monetary ratios and how they have shaped up over the past few years. In the conclusion, I will also give some commentary on how COVID-19 could also have an impact on these ratios. This post was inspired from an old article which Niranjan Rajadhyaksha had written in his Café Economics column dated September 3, 2019.



Q1. What are the different components of money which the RBI defines?

A1. There are 5 broad components of money which the RBI defines and I have listed them as below:

·   M0 – Currency in circulation + Banker’s deposit with the RBI (popularly called as CRR) + other deposits with RBI. M0 is popularly called as 💡“Reserve Money”💡

·   M1 – Currency in circulation - cash available with the banks + demand deposits with the banks (eg: savings account) + other deposits with RBI. M1 is popularly called as 💡“Narrow Money”💡

·   M2 – M1 + post office saving bank deposits

·   M3 – M1 + time deposits with banks (eg: fixed deposits). M3 is popularly called as 💡“Broad Money”💡

·   M4 – M3 + Total post office deposits

Though there are 5 components, I would like you’ll to focus on “reserve money – M0”, “narrow money – M1” and “broad money – M3”.

In simple terms, narrow money includes the money which is available with the public money in savings bank accounts. Broad money includes the component of narrow money various time deposits (like fixed deposits).

Q2. What is the concept of money multiplier?🤔

A2. If your grandmother🧙‍♀️ gives you a gift of Rs 50,000/- on completion of your post-graduation🏆🏆, say your immediate response is to deposit the money into your bank account. The money which your grandmother had is called as currency in circulation. Once the money is deposited into the bank account, the bank will keep some portion of it aside (say 20%) and lend the balance (80%). The amount which is kept aside is called as 💡“reserve requirement”💡 which in India’s case is popularly called as “Cash reserve ratio and statutory liquidity ratio”. The amount which is lent falls into the bank account of some other person and thus will be a deposit in either the same bank or another bank. This deposit can again be lent and this process keeps on going.

 *Therefore the original currency in circulation multiplied across this process of deposit and lending and thus created “money supply” in the economy*

In case you are confused as to how this original currency in circulation came from, then the answer to it is that it was printed by the RBI and formed part of the “Reserve Money/ M0”. Thus the reserve money multiplied and led to money supply in the economy.

*In mathematical terms, we calculate money multiplier as Broad Money (M3) / Reserve Money (M0).*

Q3. What is income velocity of money?

A3. The income velocity of money tells us about the average number of times a unit of currency is used to purchase goods and services within a given period of time. In simple words it means the speed at which the money is getting exchanged in the economy.

*Higher this number would mean higher exchange of goods and services in the economy which is reflective of healthy and expansionary economy.*


*Mathematically this term is calculated as (GDP of the economy in a year / Broad money).* However we can also have narrow money in the denominator. When we have narrow money in the denominator , it will be called income velocity of narrow money.

Q4. How have these indicators changed over the years, especially after demonetization ?

A4. The money multiplier and income velocity of narrow money have fallen since 2016-17 (year of demonetization), while the income velocity of broad money rose during 2016-17 and 2018-19 but has fallen in 2019-20. What do I mean when I say the money multiplier and income velocity of narrow money is falling?

*This means that the money in the economy is multiplying at a slower pace (i.e people are keeping money with themselves and not injecting it into the banking system) and spending on economic activities has moderated.*

 This phenomenon was happening in the Indian economy even before the COVID-19 development and these ratios could further worsen if people hoard cash with them and do not spend the same in the economy.

Therefore, in simple terms, the fall in these monetary indicators in 2019-20 indicates that people are hoarding money with themselves and not spending it on different economic activities. No wonder, India’s economy slowed down to its lowest level in 2019-20 (since global financial crisis in 2008-09) and the impact could be worse after considering the COVID-19 lockdown effect.

Q5. Are people really hoarding money? How can one see this using numbers?

A5. The *“currency in circulation with the public”* has increased by 14% from 20.8 lakh crs on April 12, 2019 to Rs 23.9 lakh crs on April 10, 2020 (span of 1 year). This cannot be directly related with hoarding of money, but yes the money with the people has seen a significant increase. On the other hand, the growth in bank deposits (savings plus fixed deposits) was 7.9% in 2019-20, much slower than the currency in circulation. Another ratio of currency with the public and demand deposits can be looked at with this ratio from 1.4 to 1.5 during 2019-20. This is again an indication that people👨🦰👩🦰👨🦲 have preferred to keep money with themselves.

We usually look at a number of indicators like GDP growth, inflation, credit growth, and a number of high frequency indicators to gauge the health of the economy. However, these monetary indicators also explain a lot about the health of the economy with a broad view that people have been holding the money with themselves and the spending activity also reduced in 2019-20. These numbers will fall further considering the impact of COVID-19 on India’s GDP. Though the movement in these numbers is a post-facto analysis about the health of the economy but in order to increase these ratios the psychological view of holding cash among individuals and risk aversion towards lending by banks will be critical determinants to reverse this trend.

Regards,
Sushant

No comments:

Post a Comment